Von der Leyen’s Commission: The ones to watch at Europe’s new top table

Scroll down to content
European Commission President-elect Ursula von der Leyen addresses the European Parliament in Strasbourg, 27 November 2019

The first woman to take on the EU Commission presidency, Germany’s Ursula von der Leyen, has urged lawmakers to approve her team and “give Europe a new start” with a focus on climate change and technology.

Wednesday’s vote in the European Parliament in Strasbourg requires a simple majority to take office on 1 December, a month later than planned.

Mrs von der Leyen vowed to build a team to lead the EU’s executive body made up of equal numbers of men and women.

Her list of 27 will see 12 women get a seat at the top table – herself included – after weeks of stumbling over nominees grilled by members of the European Parliament (MEPs).

There will be no UK commissioner. Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s government opted not to nominate a candidate even though the UK has not yet left the union and the EU has since launched legal action.

“One member of our family intends to leave our union,” Mrs von der Leyen said on Wednesday to cheers and clapping from the UK’s Brexit Party MEPs. “A vast majority of this house appears to be very happy that the small [Brexit] group will not be able to clap as loudly any more,” she said to rapturous applause.

A number of MEPs voting on Wednesday voiced objections to some of the chosen candidates, citing conflicts of interest.

So who are some of the key names to look out for?

Thierry Breton (France): Internal Market and Services

Thierry Breton listens during a hearing before the European Parliament in Brussels, 14 November 2019

“I sold all my shares,” the ex-head of French tech giant Atos assured MEPs, when they raised questions about possible conflicts of interest earlier this month.

The 64-year-old was France’s second candidate for the von der Leyen team after President Emmanuel Macron’s preferred choice, Sylvie Goulard, was rejected.

Mr Breton has stressed the need to regulate the tech sector and bring in single market rules, which he argues would help address challenges from competition outside the EU.

Thierry Breton caused a bit of a stir at the helm of Atos in 2011 when he announced a plan to ban internal email exchanges. The idea, aimed at removing distractions and improving individual productivity, was described at the time as both “bold” and “stupid”.

In the years that followed, email correspondence at Atos was gradually replaced with an internal messaging system – a move credited with helping to boost growth.

Margrethe Vestager (Denmark): Vice-President – Europe fit for the Digital Age

Margrethe Vestager, EU Commissioner for Competition

A big name in Danish politics, Ms Vestager has spent the past five years as EU competition commissioner, spearheading EU anti-trust investigations that have ended in big fines for US technology giants Google and Apple.

Her nomination for this new, high-powered role may well have caused technology firms to sit up and take note, as it includes digital reform as well as competition policy.

She has already earned the wrath of US President Donald Trump: “Your tax lady, she really hates the US,” he is reported to have told her previous boss, Jean-Claude Juncker.

But Ms Vestager, 51, believes companies must pay their way.

She has previously served as Denmark’s economy and interior minister.

Oliver Varhelyi (Hungary): Neighbourhood and Enlargement policy

Hungary's Oliver Varhelyi attends a hearing before the European Parliament in Brussels, 14 November 2019

Mr Varhelyi, 47, was only given the green light last week – a move described by Hungary’s nationalist Prime Minister Viktor Orban as the country’s “biggest diplomatic success” in a decade.

Hungary’s government has clashed with the EU over issues of rule of law and migration in recent years – passing several laws in breach of EU treaties.

Mr Orban said Hungarians could now “increase their influence in European politics” in areas such as migration through EU candidate countries in the Balkans.

During his confirmation hearing earlier this month, MEPs questioned whether Mr Varhelyi’s loyalties lay with the bloc as a whole or with Mr Orban. He insisted he would not take orders from Budapest.

The previous Hungarian nominee, Laszlo Trocsanyi, was blocked ahead of confirmation hearings over a conflict of interest.

Dubravka Suica (Croatia): Vice-President for Democracy and Demography

European Commission vice-president in charge for Democracy and Demography Dubravka Suica arrives for her hearing at the European Parliament in Brussels, 3 October 2019

Ms Suica has been an MEP since Croatia joined the EU in 2013 and has vowed to use her position to address Europe’s demographic change, describing it as “a root cause of some people losing faith in our democracy”.

The former mayor of Dubrovnik – the first female to secure the role – has also said that she will work “towards the rule of law and transparency”. But the 62-year-old has come under fire for a lack of transparency relating to her own personal wealth.

“Can you reveal how you acquired a wealth of more than €5m ($5.5m; £4.3m)?” Ms Suica was asked by a member of the European Parliament at a hearing.

She said the figure included the salary of her husband, who had received a significant wage during his many years as a sea captain, and that “everything is clear and transparent”.

Ms Suica was also asked about her previous decision to vote against European resolutions calling for greater women’s rights, in particular relating to sexual and reproductive health.

Frans Timmermans (Netherlands): Vice-President for European Green Deal

Frans Timmermans gives a talk as the EU Commission headquarters, 15 April 2019

The centre-left politician has already shown a preparedness to tackle the climate crisis, helping to steer through EU legislation banning plastic straws in his role as first vice-president of the Commission.

The multilingual 58-year-old, who has been given the task of helping to implement further environmental policies, received a standing ovation earlier this month when he suggested “a pivotal role” for hydrogen in Europe.

Mr Timmermans said this was because Europe already has a lot of gas infrastructure in place, making the transition smoother and cost-effective.

He has also previously negotiated the EU’s 2016 deal with Turkey to reduce the flow of migrants and has warned of the risks of nationalism.

Margaritis Schinas (Greece): Vice-President for Promoting the European Way of Life

Greece's Margaritis Schinas speaks during his confirmation hearing before the European Parliament in Brussels, 3 October 2019

This new and broad role gives the current EU Commission spokesman and member of Greece’s governing centre-right party New Democracy oversight of migration, security, employment and education.

The very name of his job is a delicate issue. It had to be changed after the previous title – Protecting Our European Way of Life – was criticised for tapping into right-wing rhetoric. It was described by MEPs as “grotesque” and by Amnesty International as “worrying”.

Mr Schinas’ top two priorities, according to Greek Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis, should be to reform the EU’s asylum system and increase border protection.

Greece has seen a big rise in migrant numbers crossing from Turkey. Five of its islands are under tremendous strain from the arrival of tens of thousands of asylum seekers.

Phil Hogan (Ireland): Trade

European Commissioner designate for Trade Phil Hogan at the European Parliament 30 September 2019

Mr Hogan – referred to as “Big Phil” – is nominated to become the EU’s point man in any future Brexit trade negotiations with the UK.

The 59-year-old has said he looks forward to working with the UK in due course, if and when Britain’s exit from the EU takes place during his tenure.

But, while it is not clear who will be leading future negotiations on the UK side, Mr Hogan has previously been vocally derisive of Prime Minister Johnson and his approach to Brexit.

“The UK government’s only Churchillian legacy will be – ‘never have so few done so much damage to so many’. Gambling with peace and the Good Friday Agreement is not good politics,” he wrote in the Irish Independent newspaper in August.

Jutta Urpilainen (Finland): International Partnerships

European Commissioner-designate in charge of International Partnerships Jutta Urpilainen at the European Parliament in Brussels, Belgium, 1 October 2019

Ms Urpilainen, the first woman to lead Finland’s Social Democratic Party (SDP) in 2008, has said gender equality should be a top priority for all existing and developing EU programmes and policies.

Speaking to MEPs in October, the 44-year-old described the EU’s 2030 agenda for sustainable development goals as “a golden opportunity” for Europe to lead the way in eradicating poverty worldwide.

At the age of 22, she set up the Finnish European youth movement, under the umbrella of the Young European Federalists – a group seeking to promote “a more democratic Europe”.

Later, as Finland’s finance minister in 2012, Ms Urpilainen wrote on her website that her country “would prefer to consider leaving the eurozone rather than to pay other countries’ debts in the currency area”. The remark led to questions about the SDP’s position on Finland’s membership and the party was forced to issue a series of denials and clarifications.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: